As I expected the Arroyo Craftsman light fixture quality is strong and well made. I gave it 4 stars for the less than quality finish on the fixture metal. I selected the pewter color. The metal finish is NOT plated but spray painted and scratches EXTREMELY easy so be very careful not to use any material near the finish that could ding or scratch. Up on the wall at a distance you cannot see the slight paint spray blemishes nor small scratches. I have two of these lights up and it works and looks great, i.e., high up on the wall. Possibly they are trying to meet customer tastes in offering a wide selection of finishes. Might be good to identify up front which are plated or spray paint.
Not to the quality I had expected from this manufacturing group.